I have been wanting to try a book by Mrs. Ihli for awhile. I have heard good things about her writing, story lines, characters, and pacing. I finally caved in and bought Ask for Andrea since the library's copy was lost and not being replaced.
The premise of three ghosts haunting their killer is fun and does remind me a bit of a Christmas Carol aspect when I first read the description but it was nothing like that. Each ghost had a different personality and ways to cope with being deceased. I liked that about them. Since the whole story was told from the point the view of the ghosts it is hard to get to know the killer, he was always portrayed as a monster and something less then human according to the women. I get that and I liked that the women all held true with their belief of the murdered even when he was living a "normal" life.
The story starts out with a good hook and then moves along okay. The middle part is a bit slow, I had no problem stopping and coming back to it thus I would not classify it as as popcorn thriller. Despite this I was engaged, rooting for the women, and wanting justice. The free bonus story that is on Mrs. Ihli's website is a great final twist and I feel the biggest twist for the story overall.






